If I had to choose at the end of the day. I think I would choose Gow because of its story and epicness. But I think RDR2 should win purely on how much time and effort has been put into meticulous little details and The grinchshank redemption t-shirt. Not to say Santa Monica didn’t work hard, they did, but Red Dead clearly has so much effort put in by everyone involved that, even if you think it’s too slow (western style), you have to acknowledge it.